The catch is very fiddly on the pair I received. Upon taking them out of the box, one of the earrings would not click back into place. This was before I could even try them on. I took them back to my local branch who explained that the gold had bent out of shape as it was quite soft, probably when it was inserted into the card in the earring box it was sent in from by the online shop. She went out to the back of the shop and adjusted it so that it 'caught' again on the earring. Upon trying them on to wear the next day, the earring piece again moved so that it wouldn't fasten. I went back to the shop where they offered to replace with another pair, but I requested a refund as they were proving to be too fiddly to wear. I received a refund with no problems. I was disappointed as they are a lovely design, just too fiddly/soft in the catch.